Eyewitnesses Testimonies – A Critical Analysis of its Reliability and Admissibility under the Indian Evidence Act

Metrics Not Available becuase DOI is Not Assigned [Get DOI]

Publication Information

Journal Title: Asian Journal of Multidisciplinary Research & Review
Author(s): Isha Ahlawat
Published On: 31/08/2022
Volume: 3
Issue: 4
First Page: 134
Last Page: 141
ISSN: 2582-8088
Publisher: The Law Brigade Publisher

Cite this Article

Isha Ahlawat, Eyewitnesses Testimonies – A Critical Analysis of its Reliability and Admissibility under the Indian Evidence Act, Volume 3 Issue 4, Asian Journal of Multidisciplinary Research & Review, 134-141, Published on 31/08/2022, Available at https://ajmrr.thelawbrigade.com/article/eyewitnesses-testimonies-a-critical-analysis-of-its-reliability-and-admissibility-under-the-indian-evidence-act/

Abstract

More than once, eyewitness testimony, given at the right time and the right place has changed the course of world history. The eyewitness testimonies of the disciples of Jesus who authored the Gospels found their way to the New Testament and helped establish and spread a major world religion. The eyewitness accounts of Holocaust survivors have kept alive the memory of all those who perished in Nazi Germany. At the Nuremberg Trials, eyewitness testimonies of survivor like Marie-Claude Vaillant-Couturier and perpetrators such as Hermann Göring and Otto Ohlendorf were instrumental in shedding light on the Jewish genocide and securing conviction.

However, eyewitness testimonies have come under sharp criticisms in recent times. This paper attempts to examine the reliability and admissibility of eyewitness testimony in India. By studying the common practice of courts, the paper sheds light on numerous problems that arise with respect to the application of and the jurisprudence behind eyewitness testimonies. It is seen that courts in India tend to place unfounded confidence upon eyewitness testimony, often at the cost of examining other more compelling and scientifically sound evidence. This practice has had severely adverse ramifications for the rights of the accused and has on some occasions led to wrongful convictions too. The paper concludes by offering explanations from the field of psychology and neuroscience on why eyewitness accounts are unreliable, and an alternative way forward is suggested.

Keywords: Indian Evidence Act, Eyewitness testimony, Criminal justice, Admissibility of evidence

Share this research

Latest Publications

AJMRR

License Information

Copyright © 2023

Isha Ahlawat

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Ownership and Licensing:

Authors of this research paper submitted to the Journal of Science & Technology retain the copyright of their work while granting the journal certain rights. Authors maintain ownership of the copyright and have granted the journal a right of first publication. Simultaneously, authors agreed to license their research papers under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-SA 4.0) License.

License Permissions:

Under the CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 License, others are permitted to share and adapt the work, as long as proper attribution is given to the authors and acknowledgement is made of the initial publication in the Journal of Science & Technology. This license allows for the broad dissemination and utilization of research papers.

Additional Distribution Arrangements:

Authors are free to enter into separate contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal’s published version of the work. This may include posting the work to institutional repositories, publishing it in journals or books, or other forms of dissemination. In such cases, authors are requested to acknowledge the initial publication of the work in the Journal of Science & Technology.

Online Posting:

Authors are encouraged to share their work online, including in institutional repositories, disciplinary repositories, or on their personal websites. This permission applies both prior to and during the submission process to the Journal of Science & Technology. Online sharing enhances the visibility and accessibility of the research papers.

Responsibility and Liability:

Authors are responsible for ensuring that their research papers do not infringe upon the copyright, privacy, or other rights of any third party. The Journal of Science & Technology and The Science Brigade Publishers disclaim any liability or responsibility for any copyright infringement or violation of third-party rights in the research papers.

Scroll to Top